Complete Good/Bad Idea Tally

Lately, lots of fans have been asking in the comments if there is an official list of "good/bad ideas" available to look at. While the Wiki up until now told us what every experiment's verdict was and the percentage of "good ideas" that each microwave girl received during her run, there hasn't been an actual tally of "good/bad ideas." That is what this page will represent. Jon has long told new viewers who doubt that there is ever a "good idea" verdict that around ⅓ of the verdicts turn out to be "good ideas." Is this statistic true? Overall, does ⅓ of the verdicts consist of "good ideas"? And how about the breakdown by season? As Jory would say, let's find out!

Overall Total
See below for how non-"good"/"bad" ideas were counted.

Season 1

 * Unnamed's Good Ideas: 8
 * Unnamed's Bad Ideas: 10

Percentage of "Good Ideas": 44.4%

Season 2

 * Diane's Good Ideas: 11
 * Diane's Bad Ideas: 13
 * Diane's Stupid Ideas (counted as "bad" in overall percentage): 2

Percentage of "Good Ideas": 42.3%

Season 3

 * Total Good Ideas: 10 (8: Sandra; 2: Helga)
 * Total Bad Ideas: 20 (9: Sandra; 11: Helga)
 * Total Redurple Ideas (counted as "bad"): 1 (Sandra)

Percentage of "Good Ideas": 32.3%

Season 4

 * Total Good Ideas: 11 (0: Helga; 11: Lacey)
 * Total Bad Ideas: 16 (2: Helga; 14: Lacey)

Percentage of "Good Ideas": 40.7%

Season 5

 * Total Good Ideas: 9 (0: Vanessa; 4: Tracy; 4.5: Whoopi; 0.5: Jasmine)

'''Note: Even though Whoopi is given the spray paint's verdict in her individual percentage of "good ideas," it can only be counted once for the total. Thus, it will be given as a half point for each of the microwaves.'''


 * Total Bad Ideas: 17 (1: Vanessa; 9: Tracy; 7: Whoopi; 0: Jasmine)
 * Total Unpatriotic Ideas (counted as "bad"): 1 (Vanessa)
 * Total Box Office Bombs (counted as "bad"): 1 (Tracy)
 * Total Darn Good Ideas (counted as "good"): 1 (Tracy)
 * Total "Yes, It Microwaves!" (counted as "good"): 1 (Tracy)
 * Total Boring Ideas (counted as "bad"): 1 (Whoopi)

Percentage of "Good Ideas": 35.5%

Season 6

 * Total Good Ideas: 10 (0: Susan; 0: Beatrice; 9: Jackie; 1: Samantha)
 * Total Bad Ideas: 16 (1: Susan; 1: Beatrice; 9: Jackie; 5: Samantha)
 * Total Deadly Ideas (counted as "bad"): 1 (Beatrice)
 * Total Pushes (counted as "bad"): 1 (Jackie)
 * Total Awesome F*cking Ideas (counted as "good"): 1 (Samantha)
 * Total Star-Spangled Bad Ideas (counted as "bad"): 1 (Samantha)
 * Total Damn Fine Ideas (counted as "good"): 1 (Samantha)
 * Total Awesome Ideas (counted as "good"): 1 (Samantha)
 * Total Boring Ideas (counted as "bad"): 1 (Samantha)

Percentage of "Good Ideas": 39.4%

Season 7

 * Total Good Ideas: 18 (0: Summer; 4: Penny; 2: Cinnamon; 2: Candy; 3: Zelda; 6: Melissa; 0: Gladys; 1: Erin)
 * Total Bad Ideas: 23 (0: Summer; 12: Penny; 0: Cinnamon; 1: Candy; 0: Zelda; 9: Melissa; 1: Gladys; 0: Erin)
 * Total Really Bad Ideas (counted as "bad"): 1 (Summer)
 * Total Sh*tty Ideas (counted as "bad"): 2 (1: Penny; 1: Melissa)
 * Total Flush Ideas (counted as "bad"): 1 (Penny)
 * Total Ha Bisky!s (counted as "good"): 1 (Cinnamon)
 * Total Stupid Ideas (counted as "bad"): 1 (Zelda)

Percentage of "Good Ideas": 40.4%

Season 8

 * Total Good Ideas: 13 (5: Sarah; 2: Margaret; 5: Margaret II; 1: Justine)
 * Total Bad Ideas: 14 (4: Sarah; 0: Margaret; 10: Margaret II; 0: Justine)
 * Total Goodish Ideas (counted as "good"): 1 (Margaret II)
 * Total Holy Ideas (counted as "good"): 1 (Margaret II)

Percentage of "Good Ideas": 51.7%

Season 9

 * Total Good Ideas: 9 (2: Marissa; 0: Cindy; 2: Esmeralda; 5: Penelope)
 * Total Bad Ideas: 17 (1: Marissa; 2: Cindy; 4: Esmeralda; 9: Penelope)
 * Total Really Bad Ideas (counted as "bad"): 1 (Penelope)
 * Total Ironic Ideas (counted as "bad"): 1 (Penelope)
 * Total Boring Ideas (counted as "bad"): 1 (Penelope)

Percentage of "Good Ideas": 32.1%

Season 10

 * Total Good Ideas: 17 (1: Rapunzel; 0: Beth/Miss Havisham; 0: Felicia; 6: Gabrielle; 2: Gina; 4: Shelley; 2: Emily; 2: Heather)
 * Total Bad Ideas: 11 (5: Rapunzel; 0: Beth/Miss Havisham; 0: Felicia; 4: Gabrielle; 0: Gina; 0: Shelley; 1: Emily; 1: Heather)
 * Total Great Ideas (counted as "good"): 1 (1: Beth/Miss Havisham)
 * Total Sketchy's (counted as "bad"): 1 (1: Felicia)

Percentage of "Good Ideas": 60.0%

Post-Season 10

 * Total Good Ideas: 6 (1: Rhianna; 3: Ivanka; 1: Phyllis; 1:Unknown; 0:Khloé)
 * Total Bad Ideas: 2 (0: Rhianna; 0: Ivanka; 0: Phyllis; 0:Unknown; 2:Khloé)

Percentage of "Good Ideas": 75.0% (so far)

Analysis
**Note: Post-season 10 statistics/verdicts are not included in the analysis other than in the overall percentage of "good ideas," due to the data being too skewed from too few experiments.**


 * The overall percentage of "good ideas" is about 43%, which is higher than Jon's predicted 33.3%. However, Jon made a very good estimate of how many "good ideas" there are.
 * No season has Jon's estimate of exactly 33.3% "good ideas." However, One microwave (Esmeralda) Jon's estimate of exactly 33.3% good ideas.
 * There are 8 seasons that had a higher percentage of "good ideas" than Jon predicted.
 * There are 2 seasons that had a lower percentage of "good ideas" than Jon predicted.
 * The season with the highest percentage of "good ideas" is season 10.
 * The season with the lowest percentage of "good ideas" is season 9.
 * The microwave girls who had the highest total of "good ideas" were Diane and Lacey (11).
 * The microwave girls who had the highest total of "bad ideas" were Lacey and Penny (14).
 * The microwave girl who had the most "good ideas" in a row was Gabrielle (6).
 * The microwave girls who had the most "bad ideas" in a row were Helga and Penny (12).
 * The microwave girl who had the highest total of unusual verdicts (i.e. verdicts called something other than "good" or "bad") was Samantha (5).